Monday, June 21, 2010

Guest Post: What are Modern Colors?

Kelly Berg is an Interior Designer, Color Consultant and Writer/Blogger. Established in 2003, her business, Arte Styling, focuses on Interior Design and Color Psychology with the mission to inspire individuals and organizations to express their authenticity and truest design visions. Kelly holds a B.F.A. in Interior Design from the Design Institute of San Diego, a B.A in Communication from U.C. San Diego and is a member of the IIDA and IACC-NA. Her blog was born out a desire to learn and share unique color and design perspectives and to (hopefully) encourage others to do the same.

What are “Modern” Colors?
By Kelly Berg

Donʼt know? Letʼs do a little Google image search.

Hereʼs what Google image pulls for the term “Modern Colors”.


And hereʼs what pops up when we enter the search term “Modern Interior Colors”. Relatively colorful, right?

Now look what happens when we eliminate the word “color” and enter a term like “Modern Living Room”. Notice anything different?

Here, letʼs look a little closer...

What colors do you see?

Pretty achromatic.

Iʼm confused. Shouldnʼt a search for “Modern Living Room” bring up similar images to “Modern Interior Colors?” Why is it that by eliminating the word “color” we are left with no color at all? That might seem like a strange question with an obvious answer - I didnʼt ask for color, so Iʼm not going to get it. But think about that for a minute. Basically, whatʼs being communicated is that a modern living room is most often described, at least through Google images, as a room with no color.

Google images isnʼt the only place youʼll find this theory.

Check out some of these homes from Dwell, the shelter magazine with the tagline “At Home in the Modern World.”

image source

image source
image source
image source

image source


image source
Overall, weʼre not getting much color here, are we? Itʼs pretty much white, wood, and steel with an occasional pop of red and black. In looking at these images, I canʼt help but wonder if Dwell is defining a color palette for the “modern” home? Or is that giving the publication too much credit?

Who decides whatʼs “modern” anyway?

The dictionary defines modern as:
mod·ern  [mod-ern] –adjective
  1. of or pertaining to present and recent time; not ancient or remote: modern city life.
  2. characteristic of present and recent time; contemporary; not antiquated or obsolete: modern viewpoints.
  3. of or pertaining to the historical period following the Middle Ages: modern European history.
  4. of, pertaining to, or characteristic of contemporary styles of art, literature, music, etc., that reject traditionally accepted or sanctioned forms and emphasize individual experimentation and sensibility.

Not sure if that helps us with color too much. Maybe the idea of achromatic living spaces came from the Modernist architectural movement of the 1920s to 1940s? We generally think of this movement as producing streamlined designs with minimal decorative properties - color being one of those properties.

Although, it is a bit of a misnomer that color wasn’t used during the Modernist movement. Curiously enough, Josef Albers, famous for his color studies book “Interaction of Color”, was a student of the famous Bauhaus school. And early on, Walter Gropius, the founder of Bauhaus, hired color legend Johannes Itten to teach at the school! (Great article at AT , “The History of Bauhaus and Its Influence”)

image source 
And if that’s not enough, KT Color recently unveiled a collection of paint colors that are based on hues commonly used by Le Corbusier...and they aren’t just shades of grey.

So where does that leave us with “Modern” colors? I actually found my answer by looking into the past. (Ironic, huh?) I have this amazing book, Space for Living: Creative Interior Decoration and Design, written by Paul T Frankl in 1938. Mr. Frankl was an architect-turned-designer who embraced American Modernism. He explains the relationship between modern design and color so eloquently:
“To be modern is to feel young, to be full of vigor and freshness, to be exciting to ourselves and to others, to enjoy life, to enjoy what we do and to have our work communicate to others the joy and pleasure that went into doing it. What part of our job would be better fitted to express our moods, our joys and our sorrows than the color scheme in its liveliness, its animation, its fragrancy, freshness and vividness? To be successful we must have complete confidence in ourselves.”
So, what do “Modern” colors mean to you? Are they like Dwell, with a focus on “natural” materials such as steel, concrete, wood, etc? Or are they anything you want them to be, representing vigor and freshness and excitement?


15 comments:

DNfromMN said...

I think the trend towards white is more a result of smaller living spaces for the majority of city-dwellers.

Kelly Berg said...

Thanks for the opportunity to guest post again, Rachel! I'm looking forward to reading everyone's opinions on what "modern colors" mean.
DN - that's an interesting pov. so modern=city life= small=white. White because of the perception that it will make otherwise small spaces will feel light and airy? trouble is - white won't magically increase square footage...

Marie Brady said...

As usual, Kelly, such a though provoking post that I'll be pondering all day. Cold, modern whites are such a harsh visual to live around but I'm seeing it in so many modern publications and blogs recently. I like a nice, warmer white in interiors that feature lots of colorful furnishings and accessories but without those elements, such as with the pictures you showcased, I find it so uninspiring. I guess I'm personally drawn to mid-century modern colors when I think of "modern".

Pangaea said...

Well,
I have a theory on the Dwell part of it anyway. The projects in Dwell are mostly submitted by architects. Architects want the lines of their buildings to stand out - not the furnishings and decor - so they almost always opt for stark white to show off the architectural lines.

As for the google searches - people in general are afraid of using the wrong colors so they go neutral the vast majority of the time. If you google traditional home interiors without the word "color" in there, you get pretty much the same level of colorless rooms.

I think modern colors are just what is current. So turquoise can be used just as effectively in a traditional style home as it can in a contemporary one. Avocado green is not popular or modern no matter what kind of home you have.

aneyefordetail said...

I had started a comment this morning, but got sidetracked until just now...I agree with Pangaea: people are afraid of using the wrong colors, but more than that, they are just plain afraid of color. It's hard for all of us to imagine that.... but you see and hear it all the time where I live (no, it's NOT a very sophisticated place, here!).
I had commented on a blog many weeks ago about a post asking what we thought mid-century modern colors were. I wrote of the blah browns, beiges, dirty burnt oranges etc. But the next reader wrote of the strong, almost hot, greens, oranges, yellows. Well, we were each thinking of different decades, I think. I was going back to the 50's of my grandparents uber-moderne house they built: all angular with lots of neutrals, browns etc. And, of course, the other reader was thinking of the mod 60's. So, there you go....!

Elizabeth Brown said...

I've only had one instance in which the client said they wanted a "modern palette". This young couple also emphatically stated they don't like green, yellow, orange, peach or blue. hmmmm?

The palette that was chosen was achromatic but it worked because we created high drama in their dining room with C2-052, Hot Tamale, a rich, deep red, smack dab in the middle of their living space amidst an open plan of warm and cool grays everywhere else.

Dwell has such great ideas about space. It is is mystery why they always leave color our of the picture, since it is so inherently impactful.

Thank you Kelly for making us better color consultants by your keen insights and worthy publications.

Squee said...

I just found this blog and I'm really enjoying it. As a DIY-er whose main source of information is the internet and other bloggers, I think that the influence of bloggers may actually be part of this white trend. Several of the big DIY blogs feature white room after white room (with white furniture... and white curtains... and white decor...), and I've even seen people paint their floors white! I keep seeing the same descriptive words like "crisp" and "clean" and "fresh" and "airy", and while white certainly has its place it almost seems like people are trying to out-do each other.

I agree with Pangaea that a lot of people are afraid of color. I used to do professional custom framing, and I can't tell you how many times people would come in wanting a white mat and a black frame regardless of how wrong it was for the art. Many such people ended up buying something else entirely after seeing some of the color options that complemented their art.

The almost nomadic lifestyle that a lot of people live today, moving from city to city and house to house, might have something to do with the popularity of white. It is a safe color that future prospective home buyers probably won't be put off by.

I think that your home (and your art) should reflect you somehow, and that all white on everything feels like a blank page. Personally I can't pin down the line between "modern" and "trendy" (I think it depends on use but ultimately it is mostly relative), so I just go with what I like and what I think looks good. If other people like it, great. If not, well, they don't have to live with it. Today's "modern" will be tomorrow's "omg what were they thinking" anyway.

Kelly Berg said...

Wow - these are all such great comments. Thanks for weighing in, everyone!
Marie - are you still pondering? Come up with anything new today? I agree with you - I think warmer whites are much more comfortable to live in than cooler whites.

Pangaea - yes. The fear of color. Wrote a blog on that while back too. Fear wins out during the color selection process far too often.

aneye - your modern color story hits on my point exactly! how can we possible define a specific palette of "modern" colors when different people make different associations to the word "modern"? In this case, we're talking entirely different decades.

EB - so funny. wonder what "modern" associations they were making? something had to be a point of reference for them to equate "modern" with that particular palette.

Squee - I think you bring up a GREAT point about the influence of the blogging world on (modern) color. There ARE a lot of blogs that focus solely on white "clean" and "simple" interiors. There are also a lot of web designers that create achromatic "clean" and "simple" websites. And packaging...and architecture. And, like you said, it has it's place, but I'm not sure that it equates to modern, like some people think.

I should also note, that there are also a number of interior/design blogs that DO focus on color (House of Turquoise, for example.) And THOSE feel modern, don't they?

This discussion can get so complicated, can't it?

Mary-Frances Cimo said...

I had a client who loved dwell, except for all of the white. She said she just couldn't live in a home without color, that it felt uncomfortable to her. It's why she wanted to work with me. I find it interesting that she used dwell as the epitome of lack of color.

When I think of modern, I think more in terms of clean lines rather than achromatic. High contrast.

Thanks Kelly. It's amazing to see how words evoke so many different ideas and emotions. Just like paint color names.

"Yeah, that works..!" said...

Wow - what a powerful post, Kelly! So many levels of concepts and perceptions to ponder. I can't help but think of the phrase "Everything old is new again." Design, whether it be home interiors or even fashion, has traveled so many full circles, each time absorbing bits and pieces of the past in order to create something new for the present, a/k/a something 'modern'. However, many folks' idea of modern , like you said, probably reaches back to the movement of the 1920's-40's, which in itself is somewhat ironic. Personally, I think of modern as a design that meets or exceeds the needs of the person/people/family according to their lifestyle, and location in a way that utilizes technology in a cost efficient, energy efficient and environmentally friendly manner. So I guess modern thinking defines the concept for me more than just the visual aspect of a design.

"Yeah, that works..!" said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
"Yeah, that works..!" said...

Gee - I wrote a long comment, it posted 2x, so I deleted one, But it deleted them both! Darn. Well, I'll sum up what I said. Basically, my idea of modern is more about modern thinking behind a design and not just the visual aspect of it. A design that utilizes technology that meets the needs of the person/people in the most cost-effective, energy efficient and environmentally sound manner is what best represents modern. To me, anyway :)
Kelly, this was a tremendous post!!! You presented so many interesting and provoking points. Thank you!

Kelly Berg said...

MaryFrances - that is an interesting story about your client. Maybe there's some truth to people being able to "see" a space better when it's not covered in color? A blank slate for which to work upon...

Karen - great comments...all of them! ha ha.
Such an irony, right? Modern=the past. Or is it "modernist" or "post modern" that has been confused for modern? Bottom line I think is to not use the term "modern" when specifying or selecting paint colors. It's just too vague!

DesignTies said...

Wow, what an interesting and thought-provoking post!!

I think modern design can be anything you want it to be, including colourful. It all depends on how you interpret modern. I think of modern design as clean lines, uncluttered rooms, funky accessories and furniture, abstract art, and bold colour. And definitely lots of freshness & excitement :-)

Kelly

Kelly Berg said...

Thanks Kelly. Sounds like a good way to interpret modern!